A Poll, FSX Freeware Aircraft Wish List

**Walter** · July 14th, 2013, 15:33

Holy cow! I never thought my suggestion would make it this far! Thanks, guys!

This race is getting really interesting - May the best plane win! :salute:

Walter

***voyager*** · July 14th, 2013, 16:14

My "2nd round" vote is still for the F3F.
voyager

**mustangman13134** · July 14th, 2013, 16:16

Tweet/Dragonfly for sure!

**Firekitten** · July 14th, 2013, 16:25

Second round vote goes to the ... hrm... Defiant.

**Paul Domingue** · July 14th, 2013, 16:31

Originally Posted by Marvin Carter

This one!!!

Has to be one of the top six Marvin. See post above.

Originally Posted by Matt Wynn

an FW189 'Uhu' ... i'll back that! always have loved these birds! :salute:

Vote for something Matt.

Originally Posted by Walter

Holy cow! I never thought my suggestion would make it this far! Thanks, guys!

This race is getting really interesting - May the best plane win! :salute:

Walter

I'm counting this as your vote then? This is an all new vote for the top six.

**Walter** · July 14th, 2013, 16:32

Oh, I didn't realize. Yessir, the Defiant is my vote!

**Matt Wynn** · July 14th, 2013, 16:48

Originally Posted by Paul Domingue

Vote for something Matt.

ok buddy my vote goes to the Boulton-Paul Defiant :salute:

**Paul Domingue** · July 14th, 2013, 19:45

Originally Posted by Firekitten

Second round vote goes to the ... hrm... Defiant.

It is a woman's prerogative to change her mind.

**Matt Wynn** · July 14th, 2013, 22:06

Originally Posted by Paul Domingue

It is a woman's prerogative to change her mind.

...as often as possible and on the shortest possible notice

*Ducks to avoid incoming household objects*

**flying legend** · July 14th, 2013, 22:38

My list:

USSR: Yak 11

German: FW44 Stieglitz

US: P39 (but that one is on its way I believe)

UK: Fairey Fox (but any fairey or Hawker model from the 1930 period is nice for me)

Belgian: Stampe SV4B

Dutch: Fokker F27

French: Morane Saulnier MS315-317 or 230

Grts,

F.L.

**Firekitten** · July 15th, 2013, 01:52

Originally Posted by Paul Domingue

It is a woman's prerogative to change her mind.

Just keeping you on your toes... Boxcar.

**Chris Sykes** · July 15th, 2013, 02:41

Chipmunk for me please!

**dhasdell** · July 15th, 2013, 05:37

On balance I think a Chipmunk, but the F3F is a close second.

**b52bob** · July 15th, 2013, 06:44

Tweety bird!

**rdaniell** · July 15th, 2013, 07:15

Originally Posted by b52bob

Tweety bird!

All right b52bob. Now all the rest of you "Tweety Bird" fans get on line and start voting....

Paul, I'm having way too much fun

with this thread.

RD

**delta_lima** · July 15th, 2013, 07:26

Out of what's left, I'd happily welcome a T-37. Since it's the closest I think I'll ever come to a CT-114 Tutor in FSX, that'd be my choice. For most of the other choices, an-already reasonable FS9 freeware portover exists, and since I always wondered (but never bought) the old FSD Tweety, then that's where I'd land.

Paul, this is a generous and most unselfish offer - thanks for whatever you bring us.

Regards,

DL

**Walter** · July 15th, 2013, 07:31

Originally Posted by rdaniell

All right b52bob. Now all the rest of you "Tweety Bird" fans get on line and start voting....

Paul, I'm having way too much fun

with this thread.

RD

But how can they vote for the "Tweety Bird" when they really want the Defiant deep down inside? Haha

I must agree - This is loads of fun!

**Rubberlegs** · July 15th, 2013, 07:53

Originally Posted by Walter

But how can they vote for the "Tweety Bird" when they really want the Defiant deep down inside? Haha

I must agree - This is loads of fun!

.................................................. .................................................. .................

Hey Walt......
.......Ok! Ok!...I'll going to step-down from wanting the Yak-28 Brewer and reluctantly admit you're probably right...there 'really' is a greater need for a BP Defiant for FSX. As for a Tweedy-Bird..it would have to have a great sound file to do it justice...they were a noisy little sucker!

Fly High...Punch Holes in the Sky !
Walt

**rdaniell** · July 15th, 2013, 08:09

Originally Posted by Walter

But how can they vote for the "Tweety Bird" when they really want the Defiant deep down inside? Haha

I must agree - This is loads of fun!

Sylvester, if you look deeply into your soul, you will find that you are confused....you meant to say that you really would like to see a "Tweety Bird."

Yuk

, Yuk

...like I said....way toooooo much fun.

I get all teary eyed just thinking about how much fun we'll have with whatever Paul decides to build....Thank you Paul.

RD

**Daveroo** · July 15th, 2013, 08:12

im going to have to pull for the norseman...

**Jozef Košík** · July 15th, 2013, 12:23

Originally Posted by Paul Domingue

What you suggest is exactly what I intended on doing. I was going to end the voting by Zulu 24:00 on the 14th, today or when the thread dropped to the second page as it has. So all votes beyond this post will not count.

There are six aircraft tied for first place so now we will vote on those six to determine the winning aircraft. My thanks to all those who suggested aircraft. There were many interesting suggestions that I had not thought of and are now on file for future consideration.

The following is the list of aircraft and votes based on this criteria; a suggested aircraft was added with one vote, with any multiple suggestions only the first aircraft was selected and given a vote, people who suggested an aircraft then later suggested another or voted on one and later changed their vote were not counted.

Code:









Votes
Name
Suggested by





6
Boulton Paul Defiant
Walter

6
Cessna T-37 Tweet
rdaniell

6
de Havilland DHC-1 Chipmunk
Roger

6
Fairchild C-119 Flying Boxcar
Firekitten

6
Grumman F3F-2 Barrel
TuFun

6
Noorduyn Norseman
heywooood

3
Brewster F2A Buffalo
trucker17

2
F9F-8T
TARPSBird

2
Nanchang CJ-6
jonraptor

2
Yak-3 or 9
WarHorse47

1
A6M Zero
Butcherbird17

1
Aero 45s 145
Jozef Kosik

1
Beechcraft T-34B
OleBoy

1
Boeing B-17D
Kevin Derby

1
de Havilland DHC3 Otter
Javis

1
Douglas R5D
FSX68

1
English Electric Lightning T.5
dhazelgrove

1
F-101 Voodoo
Montie

1
F-82 Twin Mustang
mgchrist5

1
F-86D
fsafranek

1
Fairey Battle
Dumonceau

1
Fokker DVII
Mr.Mugel

1
Hawker Hurricane IIa, b, & c
Bradburger

1
IAR-80 Romania
Ferry vO

1
KC-135A
b52bob

1
Lockheed Jetstar
delta_lima

1
Mitsubishi Ki-67 Peggy
unclegreg

1
Mixmaster
Bjoern

1
Pilatus P-3
Flyboy208

1
Piper Aztec
Bushpounder

1
XB-B-52
Sylvanriv

1
Yak-28 Brewer
Rubberlegs

I don't know how to create a poll as you suggested so I will leave it as it is and we can continue the thread from here voting on the top six. Voting for the finalist will end on the 19th of this month @ Zulu 24:00 or when it drops to the second page which ever comes first. If there is still a tie I will make the final vote to break the tie.

Thanks

Paul

Why should you do in FSX aircraft that are already made? Most aircraft on order already exists in FSX. Why do they new?

Jozef Košík

**Firekitten** · July 15th, 2013, 12:58

No they don't... And most if not all are fs9 port over conversions to x, and are dated now in either model or texture... So actually ,no, 99% of these have no 'good' version for them... things like the norseman and boxcar are aged fs2002 models... just because someone once made one, and its possible to fly in fsx, doesn't mean someone should make an up to date one.

**Paul Domingue** · July 15th, 2013, 13:53

Originally Posted by Firekitten

Just keeping you on your toes... Boxcar.

It is a woman's prerogative to change her mind;
but it is my prerogative to decline.

Originally Posted by rdaniell

All right b52bob. Now all the rest of you "Tweety Bird" fans get on line and start voting....

Paul, I'm having way too much fun

with this thread.

RD

Well stop it! This is serious business. :costum:

-------------------------------------------------------------
The results early in the poll
-------------------------------------------------------------

7	Boulton Paul Defiant
5	Cessna T-37 Tweet
2	de Havilland DHC-1 Chipmunk
	Fairchild C-119 Flying Boxcar
5	Grumman F3F-2 Barrel
5	Noorduyn Norseman

-------------------------------------------------------------
Get out there and campaign for your favorite.
-------------------------------------------------------------

**TuFun** · July 15th, 2013, 14:06

Kinda interesting with 3600+ views and just a handful of votes. No interested in voting?

Flying Barrel any one!!! Come in pretty colors!!!

**CP1207** · July 15th, 2013, 14:16

My uncle did some design work on the Norseman, but 1 vote for Defiant, followed by F3F if you need a tie breaker.

Thread: A Poll, FSX Freeware Aircraft Wish List

Thread Tools

Display

Stepping down.!

Members who have read this thread: 8

Bookmarks

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions



Votes	Name	Suggested by

6	Boulton Paul Defiant	Walter
6	Cessna T-37 Tweet	rdaniell
6	de Havilland DHC-1 Chipmunk	Roger
6	Fairchild C-119 Flying Boxcar	Firekitten
6	Grumman F3F-2 Barrel	TuFun
6	Noorduyn Norseman	heywooood
3	Brewster F2A Buffalo	trucker17
2	F9F-8T	TARPSBird
2	Nanchang CJ-6	jonraptor
2	Yak-3 or 9	WarHorse47
1	A6M Zero	Butcherbird17
1	Aero 45s 145	Jozef Kosik
1	Beechcraft T-34B	OleBoy
1	Boeing B-17D	Kevin Derby
1	de Havilland DHC3 Otter	Javis
1	Douglas R5D	FSX68
1	English Electric Lightning T.5	dhazelgrove
1	F-101 Voodoo	Montie
1	F-82 Twin Mustang	mgchrist5
1	F-86D	fsafranek
1	Fairey Battle	Dumonceau
1	Fokker DVII	Mr.Mugel
1	Hawker Hurricane IIa, b, & c	Bradburger
1	IAR-80 Romania	Ferry vO
1	KC-135A	b52bob
1	Lockheed Jetstar	delta_lima
1	Mitsubishi Ki-67 Peggy	unclegreg
1	Mixmaster	Bjoern
1	Pilatus P-3	Flyboy208
1	Piper Aztec	Bushpounder
1	XB-B-52	Sylvanriv
1	Yak-28 Brewer	Rubberlegs